Official Blog | Friday | September 3rd, 2010

Sep
03

Big Ten Fails Again

By Jeff Lutz

The Big Ten has surprised me recently with their grasping of the college landscape spotlight. They somehow took the normally quiet offseason and made it all about the Big Ten and possible expansion. Commissioner Jim Delany used his network and found a way to be the top prince in the ballroom. Unlike recent lack of relevance during season’s end for football and basketball, the Big Ten looked to make the biggest splash as of late. Instead, they turned a division announcement into a major failure.

Splitting Michigan and Ohio State in divisions is a catastrophic mistake. The chances for these teams to meet in the Big Ten title game are extremely minimal. Look at Florida State-Miami (never), look at Nebraska-Oklahoma (once in 15 years). Conference title games are a money-grubbing, competition diluting event that does not help out as much as they make it out to be. With Michigan and Ohio State meeting in the final game every year, even if they do play each other the next week in the title game, the first edition could be relatively meaningless.

The league that is known for its basketball championship game taking place during NCAA tournament selection, and ending its football season nearly two weeks before others, did not do anyone a service by not having a name for the divisions. In the meantime, divisions will be known simply for the teams that are contained within.

Who knows whether this call was intentional or not, but one would have to guess so with all of the contained questions during the “news conference.” I know a bad publicized event when I see one and the 11 (soon to be 12) commissioners should question the leaks and the way that this was rolled out to the public. With the excitement surrounding the divisional announcement, one would have to believe that the 2010 season is a mere throw away for the league.


Sep
02

George Kell Could Have Been Manager of the 1968 Tigers

By Bill Dow

The photo that accompanies this blog entry (see below) shows Tiger television telecaster George Kell interviewing Tiger General Manager Jim Campbell in the Tiger Stadium locker room after Detroit won the pennant on September 19, 1968.

But if Jim Campbell had his way, it would have been George Kell and not Mayo Smith who would have managed the Bengals to their third world championship.

Many people may not realize this, but George Kell was more than a former Tiger third basemen and television telecaster.  He was truly part of the team’s brain trust and someone whom Jim Campbell would confer with on a regular basis. His contributions in the front office were later officially acknowledged when he was named a director of the ballclub when Tom Monaghan owned the team.

I had the pleasure to interview George Kell on several occasions and in one interview he revealed something that hardly anybody knows.  Following the tragic 1966 season when both manager Charlie Dressen and interim manager Bob Swift passed away, Campbell was looking for a new skipper to lead the young and talented Tigers to the Promised Land.  Kell told me that Jim Campbell had asked him if he would manage the ball club.

Kell was one of the most respected minds in the game who subsequently was elected into the National Baseball Hall of Fame for his stellar career as a top third basemen and hitter. (He should also be in the Hall of Fame as an announcer).

Although Kell probably would have been a great manager, he turned Campbell down largely because he enjoyed announcing so much but also because he liked to return to his beloved Swifton, Arkansas home and remain close to his family.

Kell had started in the radio broadcast booth for the Tigers beginning in 1959 but after the 1963 season he left the booth because he wanted to be with his family. In 1965 he was persuaded to return to the booth for television games only on the condition that he could commute to Arkansas and not have to be away from his family all year. He remained in the booth until his retirement after the 1996 season.

Personally, I am glad he did not take the manager job because we would have missed his wonderful Arkansas accent as he described the game so well.

On March 24, 2009 Kell passed away at age 86. This past August 23rd it was announced that the U.S. Post Office in Swifton will be named after George Kell.

It is truly appropriate.

George told me that everyday he would go to the post office to get his mail and to also drop off mail consisting of the autographs that he would sign every day for his long-time admirers and fans who would contact him. He never turned down an autograph request.

For me, nobody, and I mean nobody, epitomizes Tiger Baseball more than George Kell.


Aug
31

VIDEO: Al Kaline on Home Run Derby (Circa 1960)

By Bill Dow

Recently when I was doing some Internet research I stumbled across newly posted videos of the classic Home Run Derby TV series that featured baseball’s great sluggers from the 1950s facing off against each other for “nine innings.”  This was the show that inspired the home run derby we see every year the night before the All Star game.

The TV series ran in syndication from January to July 1960 and was only canceled when the host announcer Mark Scott died of a heart attack on July 13, 1960 at age 45.

The twenty-six half hour episodes featured sluggers Hank Aaron, Bob Allison, Ernie Banks, Ken Boyer, Bob Cerv, Rocky Colavito, Gil Hodges, Jackie Jensen, Al Kaline, Jim Lemon, Harmon Killebrew, Mickey Mantle, Eddie Mathews, Willie Mays, Wally Post, Frank Robinson, Duke Snider, Dick Stuart, and Gus Triandos.

It is a thrill to see once again, these great players take their cuts at Wrigley Field in Los Angeles, a minor league ballpark that was later demolished in 1966. When one batter was at the plate, Mark Scott would interview the other batter, which was usually just small talk. Yet the whole thing is priceless.

Batters were given three outs per inning and the player with the most home runs after nine innings won. Any ball not hit for a home run was an out and if a batter did not swing at a pitch that was in the strike zone it was an out. The winner of the contest received on the spot a check made out for $2,000 while the loser received $1,000. Considering that back then the players were so underpaid, these winnings were relatively significant.

As you would expect, the home run champion in the series was Hank Aaron who appeared in the most episodes (7) where he had a 6-1 record and earned $13, 500.

Al Kaline appeared once, and that was a showdown against Aaron who defeated number 6 in episode 10 with a 5-1 victory.

In years past ESPN and ESPN Classic have shown the episodes, and thanks to MGM Home Entertainment, in 2007 the episodes were released on three DVDS.

I hope you enjoy this video of the match between Henry Aaron and our own Al Kaline.


Aug
30

September Call-Ups to Alter Race Again

By Jeff Lutz

The idea of the September call-up is very simple. Players that are sniffing the majors get one month to play in front of crowds in baseball’s greatest shrines. A team that may be well out of the race does not have to send down half of the team, instead they can look to their minor league clubs for additional talent for the team. If these teams did not have to face any contenders for the rest of the season, this would be a perfect scenario. Instead, these teams (and their expanded rosters) create battles of depth that can change one team’s playoff destiny.

Looking back at Tigers close calls of 2006 and 2009, and there’s a chance that hungry minor leaguers played a big part in Minnesota Twins divisional championships. Whether it was a Royals team in 2006 using one pinch runner after another to get speed on the basepaths or the 2009 White Sox using additional relievers, roster expansion changes how the games are played.

Is there a benefit to this? Perhaps. I do not believe that five months of the season should be played in a different fashion than the sixth. It also doesn’t help anything that these games take at least an hour longer as managers easily go through seven or eight pitchers a game. While baseball games are meant to be played on sandlots by kids looking to achieve their dream, it’s some of these major leaguers who are taking postseason glory from others.

In 2010, the Tigers will add members to their roster that they normally would not during the course of the regular season. Although this season, Tigers fans have already seen their version of a September roster-wide call-up. How many minor leaguers have the Tigers brought up to Comerica Park for their first major league go this season? With the team bounding between one fighting for a playoff race and one fighting for .500, the September call-ups will undoubtedly make and break some hearts this September.


Aug
28

The Fascinating Story of Hank Greenberg & Rip Collins

By Bill Dow

During the 1934 season, the Detroit Tigers embarked on a pennant chase during the middle of the Depression that lifted the spirits of downcast Detroiters looking for a job and something positive to distract them from their misery.

Newly acquired player manager Mickey Cochrane would lead the Bengals from behind the plate with a stellar pitching staff that included Lynwood “Schoolboy” Rowe, Tommy Bridges, Elden Auker, and Alvin Crowder and an infield dubbed “The Battalion of Death” with first baseman Hank Greenberg, second baseman Charlie Gehringer, shortstop Billy Rogell, and third baseman Marv Owen. That year, the infield quartet would set a major league record by combining to drive in 462 runs.

In addition, Greenberg, Gehringer, and outfielder Goose Goslin formed the “G-Men” a future Hall of Fame trio that saw each man bat over .300 and knock in over 100 runs.

But it was Greenberg, wearing number 5, who brought the Navin Field crowd to its feet when he stepped up to plate in hopes of seeing another colossal blast deep into the leftfield bleachers. Later that year, Greenberg, the first Jewish superstar made national headlines when he refused to play on Yom Kippur during the September pennant race.

Although Greenberg quickly became a fan favorite and someone who was very approachable and friendly, former long time visitor’s clubhouse attendant Charles “Rip” Collins told me a great story about Greenberg in a Detroit Free Press article I did about Rip’s remembrance of Greenberg.

Here’s the story:

Standing outside of the player’s parking lot at Navin Field in the spring of 1934, 14 year old Charlie Collins held out an official American League ball that he wanted autographed by his hero, the Tiger’s slugging first baseman Hank Greenberg. His heart pounding, the fair haired Collins politely asked Greenberg to autograph the ball as the slugger walked out of the park with teammate Elden Auker.

“Hank took that sucker and threw it straight down Plum Street,” Collins recalls with a chuckle. “God, it just broke my heart. I thought Greenberg was supposed to be a nice guy. I chased the ball down, and it was all scuffed up. When I walked back, he said, ‘Hey Whitey, I’m really sorry, things haven’t been go’ in so well. Come back here tomorrow and I’ll get you another ball and autograph it’.”

Although for one horrific moment, his hero had clay feet, the incident soon lead to a unique opportunity and a budding friendship.

When Collins returned the next day, Greenberg gave him an autographed ball and an offer he couldn’t refuse. ‘How would you like to shag balls for me in batting practice?” he asked the wide eyed youngster.

“As you can imagine, it was quite a thrill,” Collins says. “Hank paid me and some other neighborhood kids a $1.00 to shag balls. “Every home stand, Hank would be out there by himself for a couple of hours taking his own batting practice. He would hit those balls a mile high. I also found out the hard way how a line drive can really curve at the last minute. Sometimes I would also get him a sandwich or take his suits to Sam the Tailor on Trumbull Avenue.”

Collins grew up with his grandmother Genevieve Baker at 2834 National (now Cochrane) with a view from his front lawn of the flags flying high atop the roof of Navin Field’s leftfield pavilion.

“My grandmother was a huge Tiger fan who was always glued to the radio listening to Ty Tyson’s play by play. Sometimes Hank would drop me off at the house in his Silver Hudson Terraplane and talk with her. Believe me, it was her moment in the sun,” Collins says. “For years he would send us a Christmas card.”

Greenberg’s kindness and interest in the neighborhood kid never wavered.

“Hammerin Hank” soon found other employment at the ballpark for Collins. “He took me in to see the clubhouse manager, and said, ‘Take care of Whitey for me, okay?’” Collins says.

In the summer of ’34, and part of the 1935 season, as Mickey Cochrane’s Bengals were capturing two American League titles, Collins served as a batboy and clubhouse assistant for Tiger opponents.

In the middle of the ’35 season, Collins lost his position when the Tigers hired another kid to take his place. “I told Hank what happened and he still went to bat for me. But he later said, “The chief (Cochrane) has a friend that wants his kid in there. If it was anybody but Mickey I could straighten this out, Whitey.” As a consolation, Greenberg would often give Collins a ticket in section 17 behind home plate, a program, soda, and a box of popcorn.

Proudly displayed in his living room is a blackened ball covered in licorice, tobacco juice, and dirt that had served as the infield ball for the Tigers’ “Battalion of Death” the record hitting 1934 infield of Greenberg, Gehringer, Rogell, and Owen. And tucked away in a shoebox hidden in a rear bedroom, is one of Greenberg’s first baseman’s gloves given to him by the slugger during the ’34 season.

When Greenberg’s and Gehringer’s numbers were retired in a special ceremony at Tiger Stadium in 1982, Collins brought the treasured glove into work and asked his hero to sign it.

“I said, ‘Hank, remember me, you called me “Whitey” as a kid and you gave me this mitt.’ He couldn’t believe it. We had a nice chat after he signed the glove. Hank was just a classy guy, and a special part of my life,” Collins says.

Hank Greenberg had more than made up for hurling a kid’s baseball down Plum Street more than three-quarters of a century ago.


Aug
26

Damon Saga Illustrates the Impact of Fans

By Jeff Lutz

Johnny Damon was never going to be on the Red Sox. That realization did not come in August of 2010, but probably some time in late 2005 when he left Boston to join forces with their hated rivals, the New York Yankees.

Much like Chris Chelios before him, Damon quickly realized how much rabid fans can impact someone’s feelings about a city. When Damon speaks highly of Detroit, it’s not some love affair with a city on its namesake river.  It’s about how it is not the one with the Northeastern harbor.

Fans and the media need to look at this situation and separate the emotion from the business aspect of sports. Damon specifically highlighted during this process that he would have immediately jumped at going to New York or Tampa. His contract would not have changed in switching teams, at this point in the season it’s solely about winning. I can’t imagine that getting occasional playing time for a .500 ball club would even compare to that of a playoff team, but the waiver wire (and the Red Sox) has spoken.

Boston’s grandstanding from the media to the management has demonstrated why Damon’s final decision was the right one. Dan Shaughnessy is rightfully not the most appreciated Red Sox fan/columnist/blogger, and seemingly has to resort to slanderous statements about cities to draw some attention.

We all understand that Detroit has seen better times, but apparently Shaughnessy has only lived and seen the most posh locations in Boston. He would not understand why anybody would choose a team over the Red Sox. We’ve seen his act before and he needs to recognize that baseball is a business and Boston is not the most coveted city in the world.


Aug
24

Babe Ruth Was Nearly a Detroit Tiger

By Steve Thomas

As his magnificent playing career was winding down, Babe Ruth was considered for the job of manager of the Detroit Tigers by owner Frank Navin. 

Navin requested an interview with Ruth at the end of the 1933 season, but Ruth was away on a vacation to Hawaii and never got back to the Tigers even though he was very interested in the job.

Navin found a practical approach to the Tigers’ leadership problem by hiring Mickey Cochrane as a player-manager.  Cochrane led the Tigers to their first American League pennant in 25 years in 1934 but lost the World Series in Game 7 to the wild pack of St. Louis Cardinals known as The Gas House Gang.  The next season, Cochrane and the Tigers won the pennant again and went on to win the team’s first World Series championship.

The 1934 season was Ruth’s last as a New York Yankee.  He played a shortened season with the Boston Braves the following year, appearing in only 28 games.  He later joined the Brooklyn Dodgers as a coach.

Lucky for us Ruth was on a ship headed for the South Pacific when Navin tried to interview him.  It is very doubtful that Ruth would have been able to accomplish what Cochrane did for the Tigers.  Mickey was a true leader and an incredibly intense player who inspired his teammates and got the best out of them.  Ruth, in contrast, was a show-boater with little discipline and was considered offensive by even those who loved him.

Hiring Babe Ruth would have unquestionably altered the history of the Detroit Tigers for the worse.  Navin’s move to hire Cochrane instead is arguably the best managerial move in the team’s history


Aug
23

Big Ten Realignment Sure to Disappoint

By Jeff Lutz

When the Big Ten divisions for 2011 are announced in the next few weeks, there will surely be quite a discussion about how it impacts ongoing rivalries. While the Michigan-Ohio State game has drawn most of the headlines, the head Big Ten offices are juggling traditional rivalries with geographical ones. No matter the result, fans will see some Big Ten schools in a different light.

I believe there’s only one result to the alignment discussion, break the teams up East-West. Place Michigan, Michigan State, Indiana, Purdue, Ohio State and Penn State in the East division, and Nebraska, Iowa, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Illinois and Northwestern in the West division. This keeps a high percentage of the traditional rivalries in the same division and potential final divisional games would be Indiana-Purdue for the Old Oaken Bucket, Michigan-Penn St. for the Land Grant Trophy, and the infamous Michigan-Ohio State game.

The result of this split will ultimately focus on potential matchups in the championship game. I don’t believe that divisional matchups should be made with this one game in mind, especially if they are only theoretical. This is very similar to why it doesn’t matter whether current powers are in the same division, especially with a team like Nebraska looking to find their identity within their new conference. Michigan and Ohio State need to be placed in the same division, just as Michigan and Michigan State need to be placed together. Big Ten championship games, like any other conference, may not demonstrate the most ideal two teams every year, but the results will remain unpredictable.


Aug
20

Georgie: A Friend’s Tribute to the Late George Cantor

By Tom DeLisle
The Detroit Tigers played at Chicago Sunday afternoon, taking on the White Sox as funeral services were being held in Southfield for George Cantor.  I found the co-existence of the two events almost unreal; incongruous.  I guess I thought that when George died … he would take baseball with him.
 
If you were fortunate enough to be a Tigers fan in the 1960s, and a reader of the Detroit Free Press, then you were treated to some of the finest and most original baseball writing and reporting in the history of the game.  George brought his genius and an encyclopedic mind — along with his gentle and omnipresent wit — to every facet of his long writing career, but it was baseball that was the beneficiary of his passion for analysis and clever study. 
 
It was my great fortune to know Georgie for 45 years.  I was in awe of him before I ever met him.  As a college student majoring in journalism, a Detroiter who lived and died with the Bengals each summer,  I marveled at his brilliant and atypical baseball writing.  When I first joined the Free Press in 1966, I was pleased to find myself working not far from his office in the sports department.  We met through our involvement on the newspaper’s softball team, and his easy and charitable acceptance of me as a fellow and peer led to a friendship that lit up almost every aspect of my life.
 
George was the right man at the right time when the Tigers turned the Detroit sporting scene on its ear with their magnificent attainment of the 1968 World Series crown.  He and the ‘68 Tigers were made for each other; Cantor hit his own personal peak as an artist the same year that Kaline, Lolich, Freehan, Northrup, Cash, Horton, Stanley et al. ascended to local immortality in a baseball season for the ages.  George was there to paint their picture.
 
Cantor was that rare bird; an intellectual in the locker room.  Some Free Press readers, even some of the Tigers, resented his references to literary history and his citing of Shakespearean examples in his coverage of hits, runs, errors, and the inanity of characters like Denny McLain on the Detroit baseball club.  But that was George.  Nobody loved baseball as he did; no one cared more for the honor and magic and traditions of the game.  No one knew more, about Tigers history, about the individuals who had graced the game, than he.
 
I think it was during the 1966 season that the Tigers played a game in Kansas City when a tornado struck part of the stadium, stirring up debris and suspending play.  Everyone — fans and players — ran for cover.  At the funeral Sunday, his brother Michael recalled how George — noting that the telecast back to Detroit was ongoing as the dangerous winds howled — maneuvered to get himself interviewed by George Kell for a lengthy period of time during the suspension of play.  
 
Georgie was playing the odds — he later said that by his figuring no one had ever been struck by a tornado in the history of live television, so he was safe on the air.  In fact, when the Tiger team plane took off from KC that night, corkscrewing skyward in the still-dangerous high winds that were raking across the midwest, George situated himself on the bouncing aircraft so he could see Al Kaline seated in the forward section of the plane.  His calming explanation — and his reason for flying in eyesight of Kaline whenever he traveled with the Tigers in the years to follow — was that he was in good and secure company as long as he had his eye on Al.  Nothing bad, he figured, could ever happen to the magnificent and graceful #6. 
 
George and I stood up in each other’s weddings in the 1970s.  He couldn’t dance a lick, and when they were introduced for their part in the Wedding Dance at my nuptials, he and my sister-in-law went bouncing around the floor in an odd and clumsy style.  “Is there a name for this dance?” she nervously inquired of him.  “Yes,” George replied, “it’s called The Fiasco.”
 
George and I were fellow city desk reporters from 1969-71, variously monitoring local mayhem and interviewing talking dogs, after he left the Tigers beat.  He subsequently became a terrific travel writer, and then a general columnist for the Detroit News for almost 30 years.  He was not only a keen observer and intriguing analyst of the local and national news scene, he was also rigidly honest and completely scrupulous in his life as a high-profile Detroit journalistic personality … something quite unusual in his day.   With the advent of television and the onslaught of instant communication, hustlers and corner-cutting opportunists served themselves under the guise of supposed journalism.  Not George.
 
He wrote 30 books in his time, most of them about sports because he could never separate himself from the drama and lure and personalities of the games.  Our lives evolved and changed with the decades, but our friendship — we never had even a disagreeable word in 45 years — was rock solid and undiminished by age.   That connection took us back, again and again, to Michigan and Trumbull downtown.  In 1972 we sat limp, in shock, in our seats at the stadium after the Tigers lost an excruciating playoff series to Oakland by one lousy run.  One.  Through the 1980s and early ’90s, we often met at our local cathedral — in rain, in snow, under sunny skies — to share the unique buzz of Opening Day.
 
In 1984 I was thrilled to take my father down to the fifth game of the World Series on a foggy and gray Sunday night.   After parking our car and beginning a long hike to the stadium, whom should we encounter but George.  And on our delightful trek up Michigan Avenue, we marveled, over and over again, how the Tigers … our Tigers … would inevitably secure a World Series victory that night.   Which of course they did.  OUR Tigers.  Over-powering everyone.  Incredible. 
 
Finally, on the night they closed the old ballpark, a 1999 date which shall live in infamy, I wandered down onto the field following the long game and post-game ceremonies.  There had been the almost mystical appearance of former Tigers stars, as they seemed to just suddenly appear, one after another, on that oddly warm late September evening .  Again I encountered George, this time on the perfect grass of the infield.  We both understood, and were attempting to savor, what we had experienced that night.
 
They say you shouldn’t look back in life, but when we slowly walked out of the ballpark around 11 p.m. — he had been interviewed “live” on the field by ESPN — George and I stopped at every corner on Trumbull, and took one long look after another at the magic that had been Detroit’s stadium.  All the lights were still blazing, and the place we had come to as children, as professionals, as fans, as friends … was slowly fading into the misty night behind us.   We stopped; we turned and looked.  With the crossing of every street.  Again and again.  Peering back in an attempt to preserve something that had been so important to our lives.
 
George Cantor’s soul was part and parcel of that place.  The stadium ultimately came down; our friendship never did.

Aug
19

Peralta Addition May Refocus Tigers in Off-Season

By Jeff Lutz

The trade with the Cleveland Indians to acquire Jhonny Peralta has ended up being a decent addition to the team. While nobody will mistake him for Alan Trammell, Peralta has seemingly become a nice addition to a team swooning towards a third place finish in the AL Central. Though the trade was made with an eye in the direction of August and September 2010, it may be the moves for 2011 that will have the biggest impact.

To name Peralta’s play with the Tigers one word comes to mind: steady. His 12 hits in a Tigers uniform add up to a total of 25 bases (4 HR), while dropping his average to below .240. The numbers are not spectacular, but it would be my guess that picking up his $7 million option for 2011 may not be the worst choice in a free agent class where everyone will be overpaying for aging talent. The Tigers have a number of holes to fill – namely starting pitching, corner outfielders and a catcher, with an infielder either third or fourth on the list. Dombrowski knows his time is running short and winning needs to be a premium at any cost next season.

Do not be shocked this offseason if the Tigers clear the minor league stack again to grab a big name in a trade. The reality for Tigers management is that it’s either overpaying or taking a gamble on an injured player looking at Detroit as a last resort. Johnny Damon was one of the rare players looking to play in Detroit, and I’m guessing it’s because Scott Boras saw a team in desperate need of a left-handed bat. Peralta is still an expensive player to be had, but his ability to play multiple positions makes him a high-prized item in this town.


« Previous Entries